Talk:Climbing in Sinai: Difference between revisions
imported>ScottN No edit summary |
imported>Champagne No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
Does this page belong on the VOC wiki? I'm not sure it makes sense to put lots on information about overseas climbing/hiking/skiing/whatever destinations into the VOCwiki in general. Certainly it's a good way for people to share their experience with others in the club, but where do you draw the line? Personally I feel that these kinds of pages are useful, but some sort of distinction needs to be made so wiki readers don't arrive at this page expecting a rock climbing destination that they can drive to. Maybe it could be categorized under ''Overseas destinations'' or something like that to avoid confusion with the domestic [[:Category:Rock Climbing Trips]] What do you think? [[User:ScottN|Scott Nelson]] | Does this page belong on the VOC wiki? I'm not sure it makes sense to put lots on information about overseas climbing/hiking/skiing/whatever destinations into the VOCwiki in general. Certainly it's a good way for people to share their experience with others in the club, but where do you draw the line? Personally I feel that these kinds of pages are useful, but some sort of distinction needs to be made so wiki readers don't arrive at this page expecting a rock climbing destination that they can drive to. Maybe it could be categorized under ''Overseas destinations'' or something like that to avoid confusion with the domestic [[:Category:Rock Climbing Trips]] What do you think? [[User:ScottN|Scott Nelson]] | ||
Same here, I don't believe that we need such a page on the wiki. The probability of someone actually going climbing to Sinai from the club is extremely slim to none. The VOC wiki is based around the club, its various activities and pertinant information related to it. Climbing at Sinai just doesn't properly fit into that image. I back the comment from Scott Nelson on this. [[User:Champagne|Champagne]] 01:20, 17 November 2006 (MST) | |||
Revision as of 08:20, 17 November 2006
Does this page belong on the VOC wiki? I'm not sure it makes sense to put lots on information about overseas climbing/hiking/skiing/whatever destinations into the VOCwiki in general. Certainly it's a good way for people to share their experience with others in the club, but where do you draw the line? Personally I feel that these kinds of pages are useful, but some sort of distinction needs to be made so wiki readers don't arrive at this page expecting a rock climbing destination that they can drive to. Maybe it could be categorized under Overseas destinations or something like that to avoid confusion with the domestic Category:Rock Climbing Trips What do you think? Scott Nelson
Same here, I don't believe that we need such a page on the wiki. The probability of someone actually going climbing to Sinai from the club is extremely slim to none. The VOC wiki is based around the club, its various activities and pertinant information related to it. Climbing at Sinai just doesn't properly fit into that image. I back the comment from Scott Nelson on this. Champagne 01:20, 17 November 2006 (MST)